I came across this error message in another question and I would like to know what is the meaning of the $: part of the signature, please?
Cannot resolve caller index(Str: Str, Any); none of these signatures match: (Str:D $: Cool:D $needle, *%_) (Str:D $: Str:D $needle, *%_) (Str:D $: Cool:D $needle, Cool:D $pos, *%_) (Str:D $: Str:D $needle, Int:D $pos, *%_)
$: is two distinct unrelated tokens, a
$ and a
:, that have been smooshed together.
$ represents a single item1 aka a scalar2.
The single item / scalar hasn't been given a name, so there's no way to reference it. And there's already enough of a parameter (the
Str:D) to let you and the compiler know that this parameter is a scalar (a single string). Either way, it's redundant.
: is a special parameter separator. (The usual parameter separator is a comma
It may only be used immediately after the first parameter of a method or standalone signature. It may not be used in the signature of a routine that is not a method.
If used as a parameter separator after the first parameter in a signature, it marks that parameter as corresponding to a method's "invocant".
(If not used, the invocant parameter is implicit.)
The corresponding invocant argument will arrive anyway, and be aliased to
self, whether or not the signature explicitly lists an invocant parameter. But if the invocant parameter is explicitly specified, it's possible to give it an additional/alternate name and/or explicitly constrain its type.
Crazy over-the-top footnotes for added entertainment. If they confuse you, just forget you ever read them.
1 A single item refers to data that is naturally a single thing, like the number
42, OR data that is naturally a composite thing (like an array) that is being treated like it's a single thing (like an array). (Did you see what I did there?) I like to point out the mnemonic that a
$ symbol is like an S (for single) overlaid with an I (for item), or vice-versa. To me this represents the idea of emphasizing the single item nature of any data, hiding any plural aspect even if it's actually an array or other composite data item.
2 "scalar" is a traditional computing term. Wikipedia's
Scalar disambiguation page lists "
Variable (computing), or scalar, an atomic quantity that can hold only one value at a time" as a definition. Also, a single item aka scalar (all lowercase) is often/usually a
S), a special case of a single item that's a Single Item container that contains a Single Item (which can be composite data being treated as a single thing).